Francis “Blondie” Geissler, '33 (Central Connecticut State University, NAIA [prior to current NCAA D1 status; then known as Teachers College of Connecticut])
 
Marty Fagan Sr., '40 (University of Connecticut, NCAA [prior to current NCAA D1 status])
 
Don Edmondo, '45 (Yale University, NCAA [prior to current NCAA D1 status])
 
Ralph Schumey, '47 (Eastern Connecticut State University, NAIA [prior to current NCAA D3 status; then known as Willimantic State Teachers College])
 
Don “The Duck” Beersworth, '57 (Eastern Connecticut State University, NAIA [prior to current NCAA D3 status; then known as Willimantic State Teachers College])
 
Stanley “Skip” Olander Jr., '62 (University of Connecticut, NCAA [prior to current NCAA D1 status])
 
Jim Martello, '65 (Wesleyan University, NCAA [prior to current NCAA D3 status])
 
Alan “Blond Bomber” Putz, '65 (Springfield College, NCAA [prior to former NCAA D2 status or current D3 status])
 
Art Wheelock Jr., '68 (West Virginia Wesleyan College, NCAA [prior to current NCAA D2 status])
 
Steve “Krash” Krajewski, '73 (Eastern Connecticut State University, D3/NAIA [began NCAA D3 status in 1976; then known as Eastern Connecticut State College])
 
Rich Rabe Jr., '74 (University of Hartford, NCAA D2 [prior to former NCAA D1 status & current NCAA D3 status])
 
Art Benson Jr., '76 (Eastern Connecticut State University, NCAA D3 [then known as Eastern Connecticut State College])
 
Mark Anderson, '77 (Wesleyan University, NCAA D3)

Mike Johnson, '77 (University of Connecticut, NCAA D1)
 
Jim Gagnon, '77 (West Virginia Wesleyan College, NCAA D2)
 
Russ Allen, '78 (Eastern Connecticut State University, NCAA D3) [then known as Eastern Connecticut State College])
 
Wayne Bray, '81 (Eastern Connecticut State University, NCAA D3)
 
Steve Emerson, '81 (Southern Connecticut State University, NCAA D2) 
preceded by University of Connecticut, NCAA D1
 
Tom Kirby, '83 (Nichols College, NCAA D3)
 
Scott Jeamel, '84 (Nichols College, NCAA D3)
 
Jeff Johnson, '84 (Eastern Connecticut State University, NCAA D3)
 
Al Molin, '84 (Southern New Hampshire University, NCAA D2 [then known as New Hampshire College])
 
Nader Shakibai, '84 (Brown University, NCAA D1)
 
Joe Verdon, '84 (Yale University, NCAA D1)
 
Jeff Thompson, '86 (Springfield College, NCAA D2 [prior to current NCAA D3 status]) 
 
Scott Smith, '88 (Eastern Connecticut State University, NCAA D3)
 
Mike Masilonis, '90 (University of Cincinnati, NCAA D1)
preceded by Stetson University, NCAA D1
 
Chris McFarlane, '90 (CT State Community College – Manchester, NJCAA D3 [then known as Manchester Community College])
 
Gregg Martello, '91 (Eastern Connecticut State University, NCAA D3)
 
Matt “Chewy” Valentino, '91 (Northeastern University, NCAA D1)
 
Jack Biggs Jr., '92 (Southern Connecticut State University, NCAA D2)
 
Sean Trask, '92 (Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, NCAA D3)
 
Mike Rolando, '93 (Eastern Connecticut State University, NCAA D3)
 
Mike Carr, '94 (Eastern Connecticut State University, NCAA D3)
 
Steve Rembisz, '94 (Eastern Connecticut State University, NCAA D3)
 
Keith Millen, '95 (Eastern Connecticut State University, NCAA D3)
 
Kevin Ehrlich, '96 (Springfield College, NCAA D3)
 
Eric Burney, '98 (Franklin Pierce University, NCAA D2)
 
Nick Wheelock, '98 (Marietta College, NCAA D3)
 
Jay Marcroft, '99 (Keene State University, NCAA D3)
 
Mike Leonard III, '00 (University of Connecticut, NCAA D1)
 
Jay Metzger, '00 (University of North Carolina Greensboro, NCAA D1)
 
Matt Schumey, '00 (Eastern Connecticut State University, NCAA D3)
preceded by Central Connecticut State University, NCAA D1
 
Luke Trahan, '01 (University of Hartford, NCAA D1 [prior to current NCAA D3 status])
 
Andy Cravenho, '02  (University of Rhode Island, NCAA D1)
 
Sean Kukucka, '02 (Eastern Connecticut State University, NCAA D3)
 
James Kukucka, '05 (Eastern Connecticut State University, NCAA D3)
 
Mike Tingley, '05 (Eastern Connecticut State University, NCAA D3)
 
Kevin Clements, '06 (University of Bridgeport, NCAA D2)
preceded by CT State Community College – Manchester, NJCAA D3 (then known as Manchester Community College)
 
John White, '08 (CT State Community College – Manchester, NJCAA D3 [then known as Manchester Community College])
 
Cody Bamforth, '09 (Fitchburg State University, NCAA D3)
 
Eric Chase, '10 (Springfield College, NCAA D3)
 
Bryan Leonard, '11 (Elms College, NCAA D3)
 
Preston Burgess, '14 (Coastal Carolina University, CLUB D1)
 
Jon Frank, '14 (Trinity College, NCAA D3)
 
Matt Goff, '14 (Coastal Carolina University, CLUB D1)
 
Matt Woodtke, '14 (Coastal Carolina University, CLUB D1)
 
Tim Baczanski, '17 (Springfield College, NCAA D3)
 
Shane Bogli, '17 (University of Massachusetts – Lowell, NCAA D1)
preceded by Post University, NCAA D2 & Westfield State University, NCAA D3
 
Adam Muzsi, '18 (Western Connecticut State University, NCAA D3)
 
Kevin Smith, '18 (Western Connecticut State University, NCAA D3)
 
Cam Bogli, '19 (Western Connecticut State University, NCAA D3)
 
Chris Zampino, '19 (Western New England University, NCAA D3)
 
Anthony Mierez, '21 (Keystone College, NCAA D3)
preceded by Central Connecticut State University - NCAA D1

Jack Steed, '21 (Nichols College, NCAA D3)

Steven Kozak*, '22 (Eastern Connecticut State University, NCAA D3)
 
Joe Stawski, '23 (Fitchburg State University, NCAA D3)

Tiarnan Doyle*, '24 (Stonehill College, NCAA D1)
preceded by Assumption University - NCAA D2
 
Troy Enamait*, '24 (State University of New York College of Agriculture and Technology at Cobleskill, NCAA D3)
 
Carson Morgan*, '24 (University of New Haven, NCAA D1/NCAA D2 [began NCAA D1 status in 2026])
 
Peter Glidden*, '25 (Southern Connecticut State University, NCAA D2)
 
Liam Hodson*, '25 (Springfield College, NCAA D3)
 
Connor Michaelson*, '25 (Houghton University, NCAA D3/NCCAA D1)

Jimmy DeGuire*, '26 (Elms College, NCAA D3)

Darren Ghostlaw*, '26 (University of Connecticut – Avery Point, NJCAA D3)

Connor Hopkins*, '26 (New Hampshire Technical Institute – Concord’s Community College, USCAA D2)

Josh Shemanskis*, '26 (Bob Jones University, NCCAA D2)

Brayden Stremel*, '26 (Springfield College, NCAA D3)