Francis “Blondie” Geissler, '33 (Central Connecticut State University - NAIA [prior to current D1 status; then known as Teachers College of Connecticut])
 
Marty Fagan Sr., '40 (University of Connecticut - NCAA [prior to current D1 status])
 
Don Edmondo, '45 (Yale University - NCAA [prior to current D1 status])
 
Ralph Schumey, '47 (Eastern Connecticut State University - NAIA [prior to current D3 status; then known as Willimantic State Teachers College])
 
Don “The Duck” Beersworth, '57 (Eastern Connecticut State University - NAIA [prior to current D3 status; then known as Willimantic State Teachers College])
 
Stanley “Skip” Olander Jr., '62 (University of Connecticut - NCAA [prior to current D1 status])
 
Jim Martello, '65 (Wesleyan University - NCAA [prior to current D3 status])
 
Alan “Blond Bomber” Putz, '65 (Springfield College - NCAA [prior to former D2 status or current D3 status])
 
Art Wheelock Jr., '68 (West Virginia Wesleyan College - NCAA [prior to current D2 status])
 
Steve “Krash” Krajewski, '73 (Eastern Connecticut State University - D3/NAIA [began D3 status in 1976; then known as Eastern Connecticut State College])
 
Rich Rabe Jr., '74 (University of Hartford - D2 [prior to former D1 status & current D3 status])
 
Art Benson Jr., '76 (Eastern Connecticut State University - D3) [then known as Eastern Connecticut State College])
 
Mark Anderson, '77 (Wesleyan University - D3)

Mike Johnson, '77 (University of Connecticut - D1)
 
Jim Gagnon, '77 (West Virginia Wesleyan College - D2)
 
Russ Allen, '78 (Eastern Connecticut State University - D3) [then known as Eastern Connecticut State College])
 
Wayne Bray, '81 (Eastern Connecticut State University - D3)
 
Steve Emerson, '81 (Southern Connecticut State University - D2) 
preceded by University of Connecticut - D1
 
Tom Kirby, '83 (Nichols College - D3)
 
Scott Jeamel, '84 (Nichols College - D3)
 
Jeff Johnson, '84 (Eastern Connecticut State University - D3)
 
Al Molin, '84 (Southern New Hampshire University - D2 [then known as New Hampshire College])
 
Nader Shakibai, '84 (Brown University - D1)
 
Joe Verdon, '84 (Yale University - D1)
 
Jeff Thompson, '86 (Springfield College - D2 [prior to current D3 status]) 
 
Scott Smith, '88 (Eastern Connecticut State University - D3)
 
Mike Masilonis, '90 (University of Cincinnati - D1)
preceded by Stetson University - D1
 
Chris McFarlane, '90 (CT State Community College Manchester - Junior College D3 [then known as Manchester Community College])
 
Gregg Martello, '91 (Eastern Connecticut State University - D3)
 
Matt “Chewy” Valentino, '91 (Northeastern University - D1)
 
Jack Biggs Jr., '92 (Southern Connecticut State University - D2)
 
Sean Trask, '92 (Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute - D3)
 
Mike Rolando, '93 (Eastern Connecticut State University - D3)
 
Mike Carr, '94 (Eastern Connecticut State University - D3)
 
Steve Rembisz, '94 (Eastern Connecticut State University - D3)
 
Keith Millen, '95 (Eastern Connecticut State University - D3)
 
Kevin Ehrlich, '96 (Springfield College - D3)
 
Eric Burney, '98 (Franklin Pierce University - D2)
 
Nick Wheelock, '98 (Marietta College - D3)
 
Jay Marcroft, '99 (Keene State University - D3)
 
Mike Leonard III, '00 (University of Connecticut - D1)
 
Jay Metzger, '00 (University of North Carolina Greensboro - D1)
 
Matt Schumey, '00 (Eastern Connecticut State University - D3)
 
Luke Trahan, '01 (University of Hartford - D1 [prior to current D3 status])
 
Andy Cravenho, '02  (University of Rhode Island - D1)
 
Sean Kukucka, '02 (Eastern Connecticut State University - D3)
 
James Kukucka, '05 (Eastern Connecticut State University - D3)
 
Mike Tingley, '05 (Eastern Connecticut State University - D3)
 
Kevin Clements, '06 (University of Bridgeport - D2)
preceded by CT State Community College Manchester - Junior College D3 (then known as Manchester Community College)
 
John White, '08 (CT State Community College Manchester - Junior College D3 [then known as Manchester Community College])
 
Cody Bamforth, '09 (Fitchburg State University - D3)
 
Eric Chase, '10 (Springfield College - D3)
 
Bryan Leonard, '11 (Elms College - D3)
 
Preston Burgess, '14 (Coastal Carolina University - Club D1)
 
Jon Frank, '14 (Trinity College - D3)
 
Matt Goff, '14 (Coastal Carolina University - Club D1)
 
Matt Woodtke, '14 (Coastal Carolina University - Club D1)
 
Tim Baczanski, '17 (Springfield College - D3)
 
Shane Bogli, '17 (University of Massachusetts Lowell - D1)
preceded by Post University - D2 & Westfield State University - D3
 
Adam Muzsi, '18 (Western Connecticut State University - D3)
 
Kevin Smith, '18 (Western Connecticut State University - D3)
 
Cam Bogli, '19 (Western Connecticut State University - D3)
 
Chris Zampino, '19 (Western New England University - D3)
 
Anthony Mierez*, '21 (Keystone College - D3)
preceded by Central Connecticut State University - D1

Jack Steed, '21 (Nichols College - D3)

Steven Kozak*, '22 (Eastern Connecticut State University - D3)
 
Tiarnan Doyle*, '24 (Assumption University - D2)
 
Troy Enamait*, '24 (State University of New York College of Agriculture and Technology at Cobleskill - D3)
 
Carson Morgan*, '24 (University of New Haven - D1/D2 [began D1 status in 2026])
 
Peter Glidden*, '25 (Southern Connecticut State University - D2)
 
Liam Hodson*, '25 (Springfield College - D3)
 
Connor Michaelson*, '25 (Houghton University - D3)