Bob Huntley, '37
signed as Amateur Free Agent by St. Louis Cardinals in '38
​
Ralph Schumey, '47
signed as Amateur Free Agent by Boston Braves in '48
​
Alan “Blond Bomber” Putz, '65
Drafted by Pittsburgh Pirates in June '65 (Round 27, Pick 6) - did not sign
Drafted by New York Yankees in January '66 (Round 4, Pick 12) - did not sign
Drafted by Detroit Tigers in June '66 (Round 6, Pick 1) - did not sign
Drafted by Pittsburgh Pirates in June '68 (Round 3, Pick 19) - did not sign
Drafted by Los Angeles Dodgers in January '69 (Round 5, Pick 8) - did not sign
Drafted by St. Louis Cardinals in June '69 (Round 2, Pick 21) - signed
​
Tim Flaherty, '72
Drafted by Pittsburgh Pirates in June '72 (Round 18, Pick 23) - signed
​
Mike Johnson, '76
Drafted by Texas Rangers in June '81 (Round 31, Pick 5) - signed
​
Jeff Johnson, '84
Signed as Amateur Free Agent by Atlanta Braves in '88
​
Mike Leonard III, '00
Signed as Amateur Free Agent by Boston Red Sox in '04
​
Jay Metzger, '00
Drafted by Colorado Rockies in '04 (Round 23, Pick 9) - signed